Skip to main content
Hit enter to search or ESC to close
Close Search
Newfound Research
Menu
  • About Us
  • Strategies
    • Risk Managed U.S. Growth
    • Newfound/ReSolve Robust Equity Momentum Index
  • Return Stacked Models
    • Structural Alpha Model Portfolios
    • Return Stacked 60/40: Absolute Return
  • Invest
  • Podcast
  • Research
    • Liquidity Cascades
    • Return Stacking
    • No Pain, No Premium
    • Research Blog
    • Academic Papers
  • Contact Us
  • Login
  • Menu

Working   papers and journal-published   research from the investment and research team at Newfound Research.

Title & Authors

Abstract

Journal of Index Investing

Rebalancing Timing Luck: The Difference between Hired and Fired

Corey Hoffstein, Justin Sibears, and Nathan Faber

Prior research demonstrates that performance can be highly sensitive to index construction choices related to rebalance dates. The authors define the measure of rebalance timing luck as the standard deviation in returns between identically managed investment portfolios that are rebalanced on different dates (sub-indexes). Using a simple fixed-mix strategy, the authors identify that rebalance timing luck can have significant implications for realized results. Statistical tests imply that the ex ante expected returns for the sub-indexes are identical and that realized performance differences are not expected to mean-revert over time. The authors demonstrate that investors can minimize the impact of rebalance timing luck through equal-weight exposure to the sub-indexes. The authors propose an ex ante model to estimate the magnitude of rebalance timing luck and to confirm that the process of equal weighting across N sub-indexes reduces rebalance timing luck by 1/N.

None

Rebalancing Timing Luck: The (Dumb) Luck of Smart Beta

Corey Hoffstein, Nathan Faber, and Steven Braun

Prior research and empirical investment results have shown that portfolio construction choices related to rebalance schedules may have non-trivial impacts on realized performance. We construct long-only indices that provide exposures to popular U.S. equity factors (value, size, momentum, quality, and low volatility) and vary their rebalance schedules to isolate the effects of “rebalance timing luck.” Our constructed indices exhibit high levels of rebalance timing luck, often exceeding 100 basis points annualized, with total impact dependent upon the frequency of rebalancing, portfolio concentration, and the nature of the underlying strategy. As a case study, we replicate popular factor-based index funds and similarly find meaningful performance impacts due to rebalance timing luck. For example, a strategy replicating the S&P Enhanced Value index saw calendar year return differentials above 40% strictly due to the rebalance schedule implemented. Our results suggest substantial problems for analyzing any investment when the strategy, its peer group, or its benchmark is susceptible to performance impacts driven by the choice of rebalance schedule.

Additional Links

  • Mutual Funds
  • Research Commentary
  • Contact
  • Form ADV

RSS From the Blog

  • Q1 2022 Commentary
  • Q4 2021 Commentary
  • Q3 2021 Commentary
  • Q2 2021 Commentary
  • Q1 2021 Commentary

Newsletter

Subscriptions


Browse Archive

© 2022 Newfound Research.

  • phone
  • email
Close Menu
  • About Us
  • Strategies
    • Risk Managed U.S. Growth
    • Newfound/ReSolve Robust Equity Momentum Index
  • Return Stacked Models
    • Structural Alpha Model Portfolios
    • Return Stacked 60/40: Absolute Return
  • Invest
  • Podcast
  • Research
    • Liquidity Cascades
    • Return Stacking
    • No Pain, No Premium
    • Research Blog
    • Academic Papers
  • Contact Us
  • Login
You are about to leave the Newfound Research LLC website and are being re-directed to the Newfound Research Mutual Funds website. Please note that Newfound Research Mutual Funds site may be subject to rules and regulations that may differ significantly from those to which the Newfound Research website is subject and may not be appropriate for use by residents in all jurisdictions.
You are about to leave the Newfound Research LLC website. The following link may contain information concerning investments, products or other information. Newfound Research LLC is not responsible for the accuracy or completeness of information on non-affiliated websites and does not make any representation regarding the advisability of investing in any investment fund or other investment product or vehicle. Importantly, Newfound Research LLC is not compensated for linking you to any non-affiliated website and instead is only compensated with an asset-based fee in the limited capacities as either a licensor of intellectual property or a sub-adviser to an investment adviser. The material available on non-affiliated websites has been produced by entities that are not affiliated with Newfound Research LLC. Descriptions of, references to, or links to products or publications within any non-affiliated linked website does not imply endorsement or recommendation of that product or publication by Newfound Research LLC. Any opinions or recommendations from non-affiliated websites are solely those of the independent providers and are not the opinions or recommendations of Newfound Research LLC, which is not responsible for any inaccuracies or errors. THIS INFORMATION IS NOT AN OFFER TO BUY OR A SOLICITATION TO SELL ANY SECURITY OR INVESTMENT PRODUCT. SUCH AN OFFER OR SOLICITATION IS MADE ONLY BY THE SECURITIES’ OR INVESTMENT PRODUCTS’ ISSUER OR SPONSOR THROUGH A PROSPECTUS OR OTHER OFFERING DOCUMENTATION.